The Lucid Post

Psychology, emotional intelligence, and the patterns that shape who we are.

Overthinking And Anxiety

Psychology says people who always rehearse conversations in the shower before they happen - who practice their tone, anticipate objections, and mentally script their responses three exchanges deep into an argument that hasn't started yet - are not anxious or controlling but running a conflict-preview system that was installed by a child who learned that an unrehearsed conversation could change the entire atmosphere of a house

By Elena Marsh •
woman in black hair in front of white curtain

I was standing in the shower this morning, water running down my back, and I was not relaxing. I was three sentences deep into a conversation with my sister that I haven’t had yet.

I was adjusting my tone. Softening the opening line. Predicting what she’d say back and preparing my response to that, too.

By the time I turned off the water, I had rehearsed the entire exchange twice and settled on a version that felt safe enough to actually attempt later today.

I used to think this made me neurotic. I used to believe there was something fundamentally wrong with the way my brain insisted on running these previews before every difficult interaction - the phone calls I’d script in the car, the texts I’d draft and redraft before sending, the arguments I’d resolve in my head hours before they ever materialized.

But I’ve come to understand something about this pattern that changed how I see it entirely. And if you do this too - if your shower is less a place to wash and more a rehearsal stage for conversations you’re dreading - I think it might change how you see yourself.

What it looks like from the outside

To anyone watching, conversation rehearsal looks like anxiety. It looks like overthinking. It looks like a person who can’t just be spontaneous, who needs to control everything, who treats a simple phone call like a diplomatic negotiation.

And honestly, from the inside, it can feel that way too. There’s a particular exhaustion that comes from living two or three conversations ahead of the present moment. You’re not just having the interaction - you’re also running the simulation of it, monitoring both versions simultaneously, adjusting in real time when the actual conversation diverges from the one you practiced.

It’s tiring. It’s relentless. And most people who do it assume it means something is wrong with them.

But psychology tells a different story.

The conflict-preview system

What researchers in developmental psychology have increasingly recognized is that conversation rehearsal isn’t a symptom of anxiety - it’s a sophisticated cognitive strategy. It’s a conflict-modeling system, and it didn’t come from nowhere.

A 2019 study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that adults who grew up in emotionally unpredictable households developed heightened abilities in what researchers call “anticipatory social cognition” - the capacity to model social interactions before they happen, predict emotional responses, and adjust behavior preemptively.

In plain language: your brain learned to run simulations.

And it learned this for a very specific reason.

Somewhere in your childhood, there was a moment - probably hundreds of moments - where an unrehearsed conversation went wrong. Where the wrong word at the wrong time changed the emotional weather of the entire household. Where a careless sentence at dinner shifted the atmosphere for days.

A child living in that environment doesn’t just learn to be careful. They learn to preview.

They build an internal model of every important person’s emotional state, likely reactions, and trigger points. They learn to test conversations in their head before risking them out loud.

That’s not anxiety. That’s engineering.

The shower is the simulation room

There’s a reason the shower is where so many people do this work. It’s one of the few places in adult life where you’re alone with your thoughts, where no one is watching, where the white noise of running water creates a kind of cognitive privacy.

Gabor Mate has written extensively about how children in emotionally volatile homes develop what he calls “hypervigilant attunement” - an almost preternatural ability to read the emotional temperature of a room. The shower rehearsal is the adult expression of that same system.

You’re not overthinking. You’re running the same preview protocol that once kept the peace.

Think about what you’re actually doing when you rehearse a conversation. You’re modeling another person’s emotional state. You’re predicting their likely responses across multiple branches of dialogue.

You’re testing your own tone for anything that might land wrong. You’re running a conflict simulation with remarkable accuracy and nuance.

That’s not the behavior of someone who is broken. That’s the behavior of someone whose social processing system is running at an extraordinarily high level.

The car, the parking lot, the first three sentences

It’s not just the shower, either. It’s the car ride to your mother’s house where you rehearse how you’ll bring up the holiday plans. It’s sitting in the parking lot at work for an extra two minutes, whispering the opening line of a conversation with your boss.

It’s the way you mentally script the first three sentences of a phone call you’ve been putting off for a week - because you know that if you can just get the opening right, the rest might follow.

Some people draft texts the way other people draft legal briefs. Every word weighed. Every possible reading of every sentence considered.

You’ve deleted and retyped the same message four times because the period at the end felt too aggressive.

None of this is normal overthinking. This is a finely calibrated social instrument at work. Susan Cain, in her research on introversion and sensitivity, has described how certain temperaments process social information at a deeper level than others - not because they’re more anxious, but because their nervous systems are wired to detect subtlety.

You’re not making this harder than it needs to be. Your system is simply processing at a resolution that most people don’t operate at.

Why the real conversation never matches the rehearsal

Here’s the part that nobody talks about, and it’s the part that might make you feel the most seen.

The real conversation almost never goes the way you rehearsed it. You practiced three versions of your opening line, and then the other person says something you didn’t anticipate in the first sentence, and the entire script dissolves.

And there’s this strange feeling afterward - not quite relief, not quite disappointment. More like the particular emptiness of having prepared extensively for something that didn’t require the preparation. Like studying for an exam that got canceled.

A 2021 study in Psychological Science found that people who engage in extensive mental rehearsal of social interactions consistently overestimate the negativity of the other person’s response. The conversations we dread almost always go better than the versions we practiced.

But here’s what’s important: that doesn’t mean the rehearsal was pointless.

The rehearsal was never really about predicting the conversation accurately. It was about making yourself feel safe enough to have it at all.

The child who learned to preview difficult interactions wasn’t trying to control the outcome - they were trying to reduce the terror of the unknown. They were trying to make the unpredictable feel survivable.

And the adult standing in the shower, practicing their tone for a phone call they’re dreading? They’re doing the same thing. The rehearsal is the bridge between “I can’t have this conversation” and “I think I can try.”

The exhaustion of living three conversations ahead

What nobody warns you about is how tired this makes you. Because you’re not just living your life - you’re living the preview of your life simultaneously.

You’re at work, but part of your brain is already rehearsing what you’ll say to your partner tonight about the thing that’s been bothering you. You’re driving to a friend’s house, but you’re also three exchanges deep into a conversation about boundaries that you’ve been avoiding for weeks.

Daniel Goleman’s research on emotional intelligence describes something he calls “cognitive load from social monitoring” - the mental bandwidth consumed by constantly tracking and predicting the emotional states of others. For people who grew up needing to do this as a survival strategy, that load never fully decreases.

The system doesn’t have an off switch because it was never designed to turn off. It was designed to run constantly, in the background, scanning for threats.

This is why you’re tired in ways that other people don’t seem to be. Not because you’re weak. Because you’re running a program that most people never had to install.

It was never about control

The most common misread of conversation rehearsal - and the one that probably hurts the most - is that it’s about control. That you’re trying to manipulate the outcome, script the other person, engineer the interaction to go your way.

But if you’re honest with yourself, you know that’s not what’s happening.

You’re not rehearsing because you want to control the conversation. You’re rehearsing because you care about it.

Because the relationship matters to you. Because you’ve seen what happens when words land wrong, and you don’t want to be the person who causes that kind of damage.

Research from the field of attachment theory supports this. A 2022 study in Frontiers in Psychology found that conversation rehearsal correlates strongly not with controlling personality traits but with high empathy scores and anxious attachment patterns. The people who rehearse the most are not the ones who care the least about others’ feelings - they’re the ones who care the most.

The rehearsal was never about control. It was about care.

It was a child’s way of saying: I will make myself safe to be around. I will not be the reason this house falls apart tonight.

What this means for you now

If you’re reading this and recognizing yourself - if your showers are rehearsal halls and your car rides are practice sessions and your mind is always running three conversations ahead of the present moment - I want you to sit with something for a minute.

That system you’re running? It was built by a child who was trying to survive. And it worked.

You made it through. You learned to read rooms and predict reactions and adjust your tone before anyone got hurt. You became extraordinarily good at something most people never have to think about.

But you’re not that child anymore. And the conversations you’re dreading right now are probably not as dangerous as the ones that trained you.

You don’t have to stop rehearsing. That’s not what this is about.

The system is part of you, and in many ways, it serves you well. Your ability to anticipate, to model, to care enough to prepare - those are genuine strengths.

But maybe, the next time you catch yourself three exchanges deep into an argument that hasn’t started, you can pause and recognize what you’re actually doing.

You’re not being anxious. You’re not being controlling. You’re being the person who learned, very early, that words matter and that the people you love deserve your most careful version.

That was never a flaw. That was always love, running on an operating system built for survival, doing its best to keep everyone safe - including you.

Written by

Elena Marsh

Psychology writer and researcher

Elena Marsh is a psychology writer who spent over a decade studying clinical psychology before turning to full-time writing. She specializes in emotional intelligence, attachment patterns, and the quiet ways childhood shapes adult life. She lives in Portland, Oregon.

You might also like