She's 63 and Just Realized She Has Never Once Told Anyone Good News Until It Was Already Certain - Not the Promotion Until the Paperwork Was Signed, Not the Pregnancy Until the Second Trimester, Not the Vacation Until the Tickets Were Booked - Because a Girl Who Told Her Mother Something Wonderful and Watched the Celebration Become a Catalogue of Everything That Could Still Go Wrong Learned That Joy Spoken Too Early Is Joy That Can Be Revoked
She Waited Three Weeks to Tell Her Husband About the Trip
I have a friend - I’ll call her Diane - who booked a two-week trip to Portugal for her and her husband’s fortieth anniversary. She found the flights, reserved the hotel overlooking the Tagus River, arranged for someone to watch the dogs, and confirmed every last detail before she mentioned it over dinner one Tuesday evening.
Not as a surprise. She wasn’t planning a reveal.
She just couldn’t bring herself to say the words “I’m thinking about booking us a trip” out loud. Not until it was done. Not until the confirmation emails were sitting in her inbox and the credit card had already been charged and there was nothing left that could fall apart.
When her husband asked why she hadn’t told him sooner - they could have planned it together, he said, it would have been fun to look forward to it - she gave the answer she always gives.
“I didn’t want to jinx it.”
She’s sixty-three years old. She has said that sentence more times than she can count. And it wasn’t until last spring, sitting across from me at a restaurant, that she heard herself say it and paused. Really paused. Because she realized it wasn’t superstition at all.
It was something she learned when she was nine.
The Moment That Taught Her Joy Was Dangerous
Here’s what happened when Diane was nine years old.
She came home from school bursting. Her teacher had chosen her painting for the district art show. Out of the whole class, her painting. She ran through the front door and told her mother before she’d even taken off her shoes.
Her mother’s face lit up for about two seconds. Then it shifted.
“Well, don’t get too excited. They might change their mind. Did the teacher say it was definitely going in? Because sometimes they pick alternates. And you know the district show is competitive - the other schools have art programs. Did she say when it would be? Because we have your brother’s games that month.”
Diane doesn’t remember whether her painting made it into the show. She thinks it did. But what she remembers with absolute clarity is the feeling of watching her excitement leave her body in real time. The way her mother didn’t say “no” or “that’s bad.” The way she said something worse - she said “be careful.”
Be careful with your happiness. It might not last.
A 2019 study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that children who consistently received anxious or dampening responses to their positive emotions developed what researchers called “positive emotion dampening” - a habitual tendency to minimize, suppress, or distrust their own good feelings well into adulthood. The pattern wasn’t about pessimism. It was about learned danger. The child’s nervous system registered joy itself as a risk.
Diane’s mother wasn’t cruel. She was worried. She was probably protecting her daughter from disappointment in the only way she knew how. But what Diane learned in that kitchen doorway wasn’t protection.
She learned that good news shared too soon becomes good news that can be taken away.
The Quiet Architecture of Withholding
Once you start looking for this pattern, you see it everywhere.
The woman who doesn’t tell her friends about the job interview until she’s already accepted the offer. The man who doesn’t mention the health scare until after the results come back clear. The mother who waits until the second trimester to tell anyone about the pregnancy - not because a doctor advised it, but because something in her body won’t let the words come out until the danger has passed.
These aren’t people who lack excitement. That’s the part most people get wrong.
They feel the excitement intensely. They feel it so much that it terrifies them. Because somewhere in their history, excitement was the thing that preceded loss. The bigger the joy, the harder the fall. So they hold it. They sit with it alone in their chest like a small animal they’re trying not to startle.
Diane told me she felt the thrill of that Portugal trip for three full weeks before she told anyone. Three weeks of looking at photos of Lisbon on her phone in bed at night, imagining the two of them walking along the river. Three weeks of private, contained, perfectly controlled happiness.
And three weeks of not being able to share a single moment of it.
“I robbed us of the anticipation,” she said. “That’s the part I keep thinking about. I robbed us of three weeks of looking forward to it together.”
What Anticipation Actually Requires
Anticipation is one of the most underappreciated emotional experiences we have. Psychologist Dan Gilbert’s research at Harvard has shown that people often derive more happiness from anticipating a positive event than from the event itself. The looking-forward part - the imagining, the planning, the daydreaming - is where a huge portion of our joy actually lives.
But anticipation requires something that people like Diane cannot afford.
It requires uncertainty.
To look forward to something, you have to sit in the space where it hasn’t happened yet. You have to tolerate the gap between hoping and having. And for someone who learned early that the gap is where things get destroyed - where mothers catalog risks, where excitement gets corrected, where good news turns into a list of reasons it might not work out - that gap is unbearable.
So they skip it.
They wait until the thing is locked in, confirmed, unchallengeable - and then they announce it. Not with excitement. With relief. The tone isn’t “guess what!” It’s “so this happened.” Past tense. Already done. Nothing left for anyone to worry about or warn them against.
They have traded anticipation for certainty. And they have done it so many times, for so many years, that they don’t even realize what they’ve lost.
The Loneliness of Fait Accompli
There is a particular kind of loneliness that belongs to people who only share finished things.
Diane has never experienced two people being uncertain and hopeful together. She has never said “I think I might get this” and had someone squeeze her hand and say “I hope you do.” She has never whispered a maybe into the dark with her husband and felt the two of them hold the possibility between them like something precious and fragile.
Every good thing in her life has been announced as a done deal. The promotion - told after the paperwork was signed. The grandchild - told after the first trimester. The retirement plan - told after every account was in order. Even small things. She won’t mention that a recipe is turning out well until it’s already on the table.
A 2021 study in Frontiers in Psychology examined what researchers called “capitalization” - the process of sharing positive events with others and receiving enthusiastic responses. The study found that capitalization was one of the strongest predictors of relationship satisfaction and individual well-being. Not because the event itself changed. But because the sharing amplified the joy. When someone responds to your good news with genuine delight, the happiness doesn’t just double - it transforms. It becomes relational. It becomes something you built together.
Diane has never let herself have that.
Not because she doesn’t want it. But because the last time she tried - running through a kitchen doorway with a painting and a wide-open heart - she learned that sharing your joy means handing someone the power to diminish it.
”I Didn’t Want to Jinx It” Is Not Superstition
Let’s be honest about what that phrase actually means.
When someone says “I didn’t want to jinx it,” they are not describing a belief in cosmic punishment. They are describing a belief that was installed in childhood: if you show your happiness, someone will give you reasons not to feel it.
The jinx isn’t the universe. The jinx is the other person.
It’s the parent who responds to good news with worry. The sibling who responds with competition. The friend who responds with “well, don’t get your hopes up.” The partner who responds by immediately identifying the logistical problems.
These responses don’t feel like attacks. That’s why they’re so effective. They feel like care. They feel like someone being realistic. But to a child - and to the adult that child becomes - they feel like evidence that joy is a target. That the safest place for happiness is inside you, where no one can touch it.
Brene Brown has written extensively about how vulnerability is the birthplace of joy - that we cannot experience deep happiness without being willing to be seen in our hoping. But for people like Diane, being seen in their hoping was the original wound. They were seen. And what they got back wasn’t celebration. It was a list of everything that could still go wrong.
The Cost No One Talks About
The cost of this pattern isn’t just personal. It reshapes every relationship.
Diane’s husband has spent forty years receiving announcements instead of invitations. He has spent forty years being told about things rather than dreaming about them together. He loves her completely, and he has no idea that there’s a version of their life where she comes home and says “something amazing might be happening” and they sit together in the beautiful uncertainty of it.
Her children grew up watching their mother be calm, measured, controlled. They thought she was just practical. They didn’t know she was holding every good thing at arm’s length until it was safe to celebrate. They didn’t know that she felt things - enormous things - and kept them locked inside until the danger had passed.
A 2023 study published in the Journal of Research in Personality found that people who habitually suppress positive emotions report lower relationship intimacy and higher feelings of isolation - even within close, loving relationships. It’s not that they push people away. It’s that they never let people all the way in. Not into the hoping part. Not into the part where things are still tender and uncertain and alive with possibility.
They share the result. Never the process.
And the people who love them never get to love them in the middle of the hoping. Only at the end.
What She’s Learning at Sixty-Three
Diane told me something last month that I haven’t stopped thinking about.
She said her granddaughter - who is seven - came running up to her at a family dinner and said, “Grandma, I think I’m going to get the lead in the school play. I don’t know for sure yet, but I think so.”
And Diane felt it rise up in her - the instinct to say “well, let’s not get ahead of ourselves” or “we’ll see” or “don’t get too excited just in case.”
She caught it. She held it in her mouth like something hot. And instead she said, “Oh my God, that is so exciting. Tell me everything.”
She said her granddaughter’s face opened up like a window.
“I realized that was the face I had,” Diane told me. “Running through the door. That was exactly the face I had.”
She is sixty-three years old. She is learning, slowly, to let people into the uncertain part. To say “I think something good might be happening” before she knows for sure. To tolerate the terrifying vulnerability of hoping out loud.
It’s not comfortable. It might never be comfortable. The nine-year-old in her still flinches, still braces for the catalogue of risks.
But she is starting to understand that the jinx was never real. The danger was never in the telling.
The danger was in spending sixty-three years holding every beautiful thing alone in the dark, waiting until it was safe to bring it into the light. And realizing - just now, just this late - that safe and shared were never the same thing. That the joy she was protecting all those years wasn’t made safer by her silence.
It was made smaller.
And the girl who ran through that door with a painting deserved someone who could be uncertain and delighted at the same time.
She is sixty-three. She is practicing.

